How Astros homecoming brings sharp reminder of uncertain future

Carlos Correa makes his return to Houston on Tuesday. Composite image by Brandon Strange.

The Astros have exactly zero regrets about not loading up the Brinks truck of cash it would have taken to resign Carlos Correa. Still, Correa will get a prodigal son returns type of welcome at Minute Maid Park as he plays against the Astros for the first time in his career with the Minnesota Twins in town for a three game series Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday nights. Correa missed the three early season Astros-Twins games in Minneapolis because of an injured finger. The video tribute is a given, and while it won’t be a particularly large crowd since it’s a Tuesday night against the Twins (even with dollar hot dogs!) most of those in attendance will give Correa a rightfully warm ovation. Correa’s glorious Astros moments are several. At the top is probably his 2019 game two American League Championship Series game winning home run over the Yankees with the runner-up his 2020 ALCS game five game winning homer vs. the Rays. After the pregame pomp and circumstance, Correa more or less becomes just another opponent.

Correa vs. Peña

Let’s be clear. Purely as baseball talents no big league team would rather have Jeremy Peña at shortstop right now than Carlos Correa. Peña has been awful offensively for going on three months now. As a rookie who wasn’t expected to be a stud he doesn’t deserve blame but reality is he’s one of the several problems in the Astros’ lineup. Correa is much better at the plate but does not rank among the elite hitters in the game. If still with the Astros Correa would be their fifth best lineup cog after Yordan Alvarez, Jose Altuve, Alex Bregman, and Kyle Tucker.

Jim Crane and his ownership partners are giddy to have Peña playing for the major league minimum salary of 700 thousand dollars versus the tick over 35 million bucks Correa is pulling down from the Twins. However, Peña’s potential is not close to what Correa’s was. Coincidentally they share a birthday. Correa turns 28 September 22, Peña turns 25. That means Jeremy is no young phenom, though it looks like he should be a capable shortstop for a few years and be so on the cheap. If Peña is to be a plus offensive player he absolutely must improve his strike zone judgment and management. Peña's 103 strikeouts with just 19 walks tells the story.

Looking ahead

Correa is expected to opt out of the two years left on his Twins contract and re-try free agency. The Astros won’t be dreaming of a reunion and are likely happy that Correa rejected their final offer last offseason of five years 160 million dollars. I’m sure Correa doesn’t regret not taking that offer, but as of the current standings he will not be playing in any playoff games this year. The Twins though are in close races for the AL Central title and for one of the three AL Wild Card spots. As for his second free agent go round financial prospects, only a desperate and/or stupid team would give him something approaching the 10 years 325 million the Rangers gave Corey Seager or the 10 years 341 million the Mets threw at Francisco Lindor. How’s that 14 year 340 mil contract the Padres lavished upon 22-year-old Fernando Tatis working out so far? But all it takes is one desperate and/or stupid team and Correa’s agent Scott Boras will be on the prowl.

Correa is a very good player but has had only one superstar level offensive season and that was five years ago. The defensive analytics say his play in the field has fallen this year from his Gold Glove farewell Astros season. Correa is a big guy who is not likely to age well defensively in his 30s, not as a shortstop anyway. Moving to third could be in his future but he doesn’t hit like Alex Rodriguez did for years or the way Manny Machado does now, hence Correa’s long term value projection further declines. Still, there will be a market for him even though he will not be the obvious crown jewel free agent shortstop. Also on the board this offseason will be the Red Sox’ Xander Bogaerts, the Braves’ Dansby Swanson, and Dodgers’ stud Trea Turner. If Boston moves on from Bogaerts could the Alex Cora-managed Sox be in play? Ditto the richy-rich Dodgers with Turner, probably much less so the Braves with Swanson. The Yankees’ best prospect is a shortstop but prospects are prospects. How do the Yanks react if they go down in flames short of the World Series for the 13th consecutive season? Bank on Anthony Volpe being their next Derek Jeter or go for a proven big league commodity?

Correa’s future is up in the air. The Astros will celebrate his past before the series opener. Then hope his present includes 0-4.

Most Popular

SportsMap Emails
Are Awesome

Listen Live

ESPN Houston 97.5 FM

After another poor performance from former Houston Texans QB Deshaun Watson, the Cleveland Browns' season is starting to look like an uphill climb. Pro Bowl running back Nick Chubb is out for the year, and Cleveland fans aren't too pleased with the way Watson is playing, especially considering the massive contract extension he signed with the team. And we didn't even get to the off the field drama that comes with Watson.

However, Houston fans are invested in the Browns' season outcome as well, with the Texans holding the Browns' first round pick in 2024, and having sent their own first rounder to the Cardinals in the Will Anderson trade.

So each loss for the Browns, means a better draft pick for the Texans!

For Houston, it looks like they have their QB of the future in CJ Stroud. And he'll be on a less expensive rookie contract for the next several years, giving the Texans more cap space to upgrade the roster.

With all of this in mind, is it fair to question if the Texans dodged a bullet when Watson demanded a trade?

DeMeco Ryans vs. Lovie Smith

Plus, we're only two games into the season, but Lovie Smith's defense was much better (with a similar roster) than what DeMeco Ryans' defense has shown thus far, and DeMeco has the benefit of Will Anderson rushing the QB.

Are the struggles on defense more about the roster GM Nick Caserio has put together, or does this slow start fall on DeMeco?

Don't miss the video above as we break it all down!

If you enjoy the videos, subscribe to our new channel SportsMap Texans on YouTube.

And listen to The Bench with John Granato and Lance Zierlein weekday mornings on ESPN 97.5 and 92.5 FM.

SportsMap Emails
Are Awesome