Houston Astros Playoff Run

Breaking down Astros vs. Indians

Breaking down Astros vs. Indians
Justin Verlander gets the call in Game 1. Bob Levey/Getty Images

The Astros and Indians begin the ALDS on Friday at Minute Maid Park.  The series features two teams with dominant rotations and deep lineups.  While the Astros come in with home field advantage and a much gaudier regular season win total, the Indians shouldn’t be overlooked.


Game One: Corey Kluber vs Justin Verlander

Kluber and Verlander might be the best pitching matchup anyone will see throughout the entire postseason.  Yes, that includes a possible Sale and Verlander matchup. Kluber is a two-time Cy Young Award winner that turned in another Cy Young worthy campaign in 2018,  leading the league in innings pitched with 215.0. He turned in a 2.89 ERA, striking out 222 hitters.

Kluber dominates with movement and effective pitch tunneling, as shown here.

There’s hundreds of examples of this sort of tunneling from Kluber.  For those unfamiliar with the term tunneling, it means that pitches look like the same for an extended period of time.  For instance, in the video link above, two pitches are overlaid from the same at-bat, a 90 MPH two-seam fastball and an 88 MPH cutter.  They look like the same pitch out of the hand, but the two-seamer darts away late and the cutter runs in on the hitter’s hands. This leads to extremely uncomfortable at-bats for hitters, because they don’t know what pitch to look for.

Kluber will be opposed by another Cy Young candidate in Verlander.  Verlander has found the fountain of youth in Houston, dominating the 2018 season at the age of 35.  Verlander was just as much of a workhorse for Houston as Kluber was for Cleveland, throwing one less inning than Kluber, but striking out 70 more hitters, which led the league.  Verlander’s 2.52 ERA is also slightly better than Kluber’s. Put simply, these two will be an amazing matchup to watch, and my guess is the first team to two wins.

Game Two: Carlos Carrasco vs Gerrit Cole

Game two features another marquee pitching matchup between Carrasco and Cole.  Cole certainly had a better season than Carrasco, as he had a lower ERA and FIP, more strikeouts, and more innings pitched.  

Digging deeper into the numbers, game two looks even more encouraging for Houston.  Carrasco started two games against Houston this year, both in May. Houston touched up Carrasco in game one.  While he did last 7 ⅔ innings, the Astros scattered eight hits, scoring three runs. Brian McCann had a homer for Houston, and both Josh Reddick and Yuli Gurriel had doubles.  In his second start against Houston, Carrasco got roughed up even more, allowing five runs and seven hits in 5 ⅔ innings. Carrasco came away with the win that day, as Lance McCullers struggled, giving up seven runs in 4 ⅓.

Cleveland has seen Gerrit Cole once this year, which was a wild Sunday day game in Cleveland that went to extra innings.  Cole lasted seven innings, allowing four hits. Three of the four hits he allowed were homers, and Cleveland went on to win 10-9 in 10 innings.  

These numbers bode well for Houston.  The Astros will be seeing Carrasco for the third time this year while the Indians will be seeing Cole just for the second time.  Not to mention, Carrasco has been a member of the Indians since 2009, and the Astros have seen him a lot over the last few seasons.  Cole has been pitching in the NL, so Houston will be much more familiar with Carrasco than Cleveland will be with Cole. Cole will obviously be looking to defend against the long ball since Cleveland mashed three of them against him earlier in the year, but getting to pitch at Minute Maid Park instead of at Progressive Field on a hot day in May where the ball carries well will help.

Game Three: Mike Clevinger vs Dallas Keuchel

The Astros win game three off of name recognition, but it will still be quite the pitching matchup.  Clevinger had a fantastic season for Cleveland, logging 200 innings, the first time he’s hit the mark in his three year career.  He also had a 3.02 ERA and a 3.52 FIP while striking out 207 batters. Keuchel struggled with inconsistency in 2018. He routinely started off games rough before settling in and pitching better late in games.  In the playoffs pitchers don’t get the luxury of time, and A.J. Hinch will certainly have a quick hook. Keuchel pitched 204 ⅔ innings in 2018 to the tune of a 3.74 ERA, which was in line with a 3.69 FIP.

Similar to Carrasco, Clevinger struggled against Houston in 2018.  Clevinger lasted 6 ⅓ in his first start against the ‘Stros, allowing eight hits and four walks, leading to three Astros runs.  George Springer homered off of Clevinger in that game. In his second start against Houston, Clevinger lasted 5 ⅓, giving up five runs on seven hits and three walks.  Alex Bregman homered and doubled off of Clevinger.

In a microcosm of his season, Keuchel was inconsistent against the Indians in 2018.  He was touched up in his first start against them, allowing four runs and lasting just five innings.  In his second start, he was much better, allowing two runs in six innings, scattering eight hits.


Look for the Astros to grind out long at bats against the Cleveland starters and try to get them to turn it over to the bullpen.  Cleveland’s bullpen is better than it was when the teams played six games against each other in May, but it still has a fair share of holes.  Starting pitchers Trevor Bauer and Shane Bieber will be available to provide length out of the bullpen, but the back end is spotty. Andrew Miller hasn’t had the type of year baseball fans are used to seeing him have, and he hasn’t been any better down the stretch.  Over the last 28 days, Miller has a 6.30 ERA in 10 games pitched. Cody Allen has also had a really tough year, with a 4.70 ERA in 70 games pitched. His numbers over the last month are similar to Miller’s, as he’s pitched in 10 games with a 6.48 ERA. Adam Cimber also hasn’t been the reliable arm the Indians expected him to be when they acquired him alongside Brad Hand at the trade deadline.  Cimber has a 4.05 ERA and a 6.06 FIP in an Indians uniform. While he’s been much better than Miller and Allen in September, he’s been far from shutdown. The only worrisome arm in Cleveland’s bullpen will be Hand, whose been just as spectacular as an Indian as he was as a Padre.


While the Astros will be looking to grind out at bats, the Indians should be looking to combat that.  Expect the Indians pitchers to really attack the Astros hitters and try to force them to swing the bat early in counts.  It sounds like a scary strategy considering the Astros lineup, but the Houston offense isn’t nearly as good this postseason as it was last postseason.  While Springer has swung the bat for a high average as of late, the thumb injury he suffered against the Los Angeles Dodgers has zapped his power, hitting just seven extra base hits in the month and a half since suffering the injury.  Altuve hasn’t hit for as much power this year, Carlos Correa has been lost at the plate, and Gurriel isn’t a power hitting first baseman that will strike fear into the Cleveland staff. Frankly, Cleveland can attack Houston hitters without having to worry too much about obscene damage being done outside of Bregman.  If Cleveland can force the Astros to swing the bat early in the count and keep the Astros from doing damage with those swings, they have a chance to upset the defending World Series champions.


Most Popular

SportsMap Emails
Are Awesome

Listen Live

ESPN Houston 97.5 FM
Astros look to avoid the sweep Thursday afternoon. Photo by Jay Biggerstaff/Getty Images.

Spencer Arrighetti's major league debut for the Houston Astros hardly went as planned.

The team's top pitching prospect was tagged for seven runs in the third inning of an 11-2 loss to the Kansas City Royals on Wednesday night.

“I would say a little bit of nerves (and) a lot of emotions,” Arrighetti said. “When you want something that bad your whole life, you want it to be perfect. You want it to go really smoothly and you want everything to feel good. But (the) reality is before the game I was a little bit of an anxious mess. I feel like I had to work harder to get my emotions down a little bit.”

Called up from Triple-A Sugar Land to fill an opening in Houston's injury-depleted rotation, Arrighetti held the Royals off the scoreboard while laboring through the first two innings.

But he unraveled in the third as Kansas City sent 11 batters to the plate.

“He started the game throwing the ball well,” Astros manager Joe Espada said. “That third inning kind of got away from him. He started leaving some balls over the plate. I felt like everything they put in play kind of fell for them.”

Arrighetti allowed seven runs, seven hits and three walks in three innings. He struck out three and threw 47 of 79 pitches for strikes.

The 24-year-old right-hander was the Astros’ minor league pitcher of the year in 2023. He went 9-7 with a 4.40 ERA in 124 2/3 innings over 28 appearances, including 21 starts. He recorded 10.2 strikeouts per nine innings and a 2.39 strikeout-to-walk ratio.

“We’ve seen the increase in (velocity) the last year or two. And when he executes his pitches, he can work both sides of the plate. And if he does that, he’ll be in good shape,” Espada said before the game.

Arrighetti was born in New Mexico and went to high school in Texas before the Astros chose him in the sixth round of the 2021 amateur draft out of Louisiana at Lafayette.

He had 10 strikeouts in 8 1/3 innings at Triple-A this season, allowing two runs and seven hits with seven walks in two starts.

“Knowing that you belong is very important,” Espada said before the game. “I think he knows he belongs. (He’ll) not try to do too much, stay calm, let your defense help you out, execute your pitches and trust the plan. I think he’s capable of doing those things.”

To make room for Arrighetti on the roster, Houston optioned right-hander Wander Suero to Sugar Land.

SportsMap Emails
Are Awesome