Breaking down the teams
Barry Laminack's 2019 Major League Baseball team-by-team preview
Mar 28, 2019, 9:15 am
Breaking down the teams
MLB/Facebook
The 2019 baseball Season is upon us!
OK, it's been upon us. The OFFICIAL opening day of the 2019 season was actually last week (March 20) when the M's and A's played a two game series in Japan; but for the rest of baseball March 28 is the REAL opening day - and if you love baseball as much as I do, this might as well be a national holiday (if I didn't have a radio show to do I'd call in sick and stay home and watch baseball all day, but alas…).
Baseball is in a great place right now, with a mix of dynamic once in a generation talents, players on the verge of super stardom, and what seems like a ton of young talent ready to become tomorrow's superstars (Full disclosure, I was going to give a few examples of each, but I have no desire to have my inbox flooded with cry baby emails/tweets about not including a name that somebody thinks I should have included).
2018 was a really fun baseball season, and 2019 looks to be even better. I'd say there are more good/competitive teams than any time I can remember in the recent past. By my estimation, we could have as few as 8 teams NOT hit 80 wins (most years that number is about 13).
So what follows is my personal preview of the 2019 MLB season.
For each team I'll provide you with their current manager (you're welcome Stephen A. Smith), their 2018 vital statistics, their key offseason additions and losses, then my preview of the team.
At the end of this post I'll give you my predictions for the 2019 season so you all can tell me how wrong and dumb I am.
Enjoy.
MLB/Facebook
The AL is top heavy, so while 4 of the best 6 teams in baseball reside in the AL, there isn't nearly as much parity as there is in the NL. The AL Central and West are the two worst divisions in baseball, but the Astros and Yankees are the two best teams in baseball.
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
Yikes. The worst team in baseball actually got worse in the off season. If you're an Orioles fan, you should probably just go watch Ravens highlights, because this year is going to be ugly.
The new front office is the best part of this team. I won't be surprised if they lose 100 games this year.
Settle in O's fan, it's going to be a looooong rebuild.
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
Alex Cora became just the fifth rookie manager in MLB history to win a World Series in his first year. In last year's preview I suggested he wouldn't manage like a rookie, and he didn't. Along with a high baseball IQ, Cora was also the beneficiary of FOUR of the top 25 hitters in WAR in the AL (Betts 10.9, Martinez 6.4, Benintendi 3.9, and Bogaerts 3.8), the resurgence of David Price and Rick Porcello, and one of the best closers in baseball in Craig Kimbrel.
Speaking of that, at the time of this writing (March 25) the above mentioned Kimbrel has yet to sign with a club. It doesn't look like he'll be back in Boston (rumor has it he'll be a Brewer). Couple his departure with the loss of Joe Kelly and the fact that the Red Sox have done nothing thus far to replace either of them and the bullpen could very well be a glaring weakness for the Red Sox in 2019.
The other big question for the defending champs will be the health of Chris Sale's shoulder. If he's healthy (and remains so for most of the year) and the Red Sox can shore up the back end of their bullpen, they'll be in the mix for another division title.
Chicago White Sox/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
I didn't expect a lot out of the White Sox in 2018 - I did expect more than they delivered - but give their front office credit for making a serious run at Manny Machado even though they are probably a year or 2 aways from being ready for big time free agents
They are solid up the middle with the young and talented duo of Yoan Moncada (2b) and Tim Anderson (ss), but they still needed help in just about every area on the club. They were one of the 10 worst hitting clubs in 2018, one of the 5 worst starting rotations in 2018, and one of the 10 worst bull pen's in the majors last year.
When you compare who they added vs who they lost, the White Sox got better in the off season, even with the disappointment of not landing Machado. It won't be enough to get them a playoff spot, but they shouldn't lose 100 games again.Cleveland Indians/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
It was a busy offseason for the Indians, but busy doesn't always mean successful. When you look at some of the names they traded away or lost in free agency and compare that list to who they added, it's safe to say they didn't improve much headed into the 2019 season.
The Indians bullpen was always a point of strength, but last year it took a step back after losing Bryan Shaw and Joe Smith, and now with Andrew Miller and Cody Allen gone, it appears to have gotten even worse.
That said, they still have a killer rotation and two of the best sluggers in baseball in Ramirez and Lindor, plus they have the luxury of playing in a pretty weak division. They will win their division again (thanks in large part to it being the worst in baseball), but will find it hard to compete with the more well rounded teams in the AL like the Yankees and Astros.
Detroit Tigers/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
The Tigers find themselves smack dab in the middle of a rebuild, and because of that there just aren't a lot of bright spots on this team headed into 2019. Victor Martinez has called it a career, and even if Miguel Cabrera can stay healthy, this will still be one of the worst teams in baseball…for now. They have some young guys coming up, but this team is still at least three years away from winning more than they lose.
On the bright side, at least the Royals suck more so they won't finish last in the division.
Houston Astros/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
It's amazing how spoiled fans can get in just a few years, but that's exactly what has happened to Astros fans (and let's face it, after suffering through multiple 100 loss seasons, they've earned it). Anything short of another trip the ALCS will be considered a disappointing year for one of the best and most well rounded teams in baseball.
This team has a stacked lineup, and one of the top bullpens in baseball, but if there is any place where they took a step back it's in the starting rotation. Losing Morton and (probably) Keuchel, along with Lance McCullers being put on the shelf for all of 2019 with Tommy John surgery, means this team went from the best rotation in baseball to a top five-ish rotation. Still good, but not 534 runs allowed good.
Last year you could make the argument that every spot in their five-man rotation was filled by either an ace or a strong 2. That's not the case this year, but it's still a damn good rotation.
I do think the West will prove to be the second worst division in baseball (though it won't seem that way because there isn't any 100 loss teams in the division, mostly .500ish teams) thus a team like the Astros will feast on the division, and that's probably why they are the Vegas favorite to win the most games in baseball in 2019 (97 last I checked).
Kansas City Royals/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
The Royals are one of (if not the) worst teams in baseball, and they really didn't do a whole lot to get better. If you believe what their front office is telling you, then they think they can win with speed, speed, and more speed.
This ain't 2015 KC, and as far as rebuilds go, so far...so bad.
They'll do their best to lose 100 games.
Los Angeles Angels/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
The good news is, Mike Trout will be an Angel for the rest of his career. The bad news is, they have won exactly zero world series since he's been there.
Hear me out.
Unlike in other sports, having the best player in your sport on your team doesn't automatically translate into success. The Angels HAVE to build around Trout, and this offseason was a good start. Adding Harvey, Cahill, and Allen at least showed that they want to move in the right direction.
Getting healthy is really important for this team as well. Geoff Blum told me that Pujols is looking healthy and if that's true, and Ohtani can STAY healthy once he returns (around May), this team could surprise some folks.
Bottom line, they've got work to do, but this should be a team that wins a few more than they lose and finish above 500 for the first time since 2015.
Minnesota Twins/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
The Twins took a step back in 2018 after surprising the baseball world in 2017 by earning a wild card berth, but I do like most of the moves they made in the off season.
Full seasons from Buxton and Sano could complement nicely the additions of Gonzalez, Cruz, and Schoop. They got a little better at the plate but didn't do much to bolster their rotation or pen, both areas that needed to be improved.
I think they Twins will make a bit of noise most of the season, but don't have the arms to get back to the playoffs.
New York Yankees/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
There's pretty much nothing the Yankees aren't good at. They will probably lead the AL in home runs and runs scored, they have the best bullpen in baseball, and their rotation matches up with anyone in baseball.
They are the best team in baseball...on paper.
The big concern for the Yankees will be health. None of what I just said will be true if they can't stay healthy, and so far this spring, that's not looking good. Staff ace Luis Severino will be out until at least May with rotator cuff inflammation, and the list of players starting the year on the DL is pretty long (Sabathia, Betances, Montgomery, Gregarious, Hicks, and Ellsbury), and don't forget Aaron Judge only played in 112 games last year.
I have them winning the division, and they are going to be a really tough out come the postseason.
Oakland Athletics/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
Listen, before I start saying less than flattering things about the A's, I want to say what a great season they had. Oakland was no doubt the surprise team in baseball.
OK, let's get down to facts about 2019 now.
The A's don't have a starter with more than 13 wins in a season (Estrada won 13 in 2015) or a career ERA below 4.00 (Fiers has the best career ERA at 4.08 era), nor do they have a starter in their rotation that has a winning record.
What I'm saying is, this rotation is bad and it's going to cost them a lot of games.
Their bully is solid. Real solid. Maybe a top 5 bullpen baseball, so if ever there was a case to be made for a team to employ the "opener" this might be it.
2018 was fun and magical, but the Red Sox, Rays, and Twins are better teams and two of the three will ensure that the A's don't return to the postseason in 2019.
Seattle Mariners/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
It's almost like GM Jerry Dipoto is getting paid per transaction, because WOW the Mariners were busy this offseason. To say they overhauled the roster is an understatement.
It's also a bad sign if you're a Mariners fan hoping for a playoff run when your GM says "We're just looking for progress in young players" and is already talking about 2020, even before 2019 camp opens.
With as many transactions as they made, and as many pieces as they shuffled, it's hard to decipher if they are really going to be better or worse in 2019. I lean worse...for now. We'll have to wait a couple of years to grade all of the 2018/2019 moves they made.
Tampa Bay Rays/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
Look, I'll be the first to admit I slept on the Rays. BOY did I sleep on the Rays.
"Only one team (Toronto) scored less runs in the AL. They'll "overtake" the Jays for last place this year as they head in the wrong direction in the standings." - Me in my 2018 MLB preview.
The Rays are a good baseball team that nobody seems to talk about. Morton was their big offseason splash, but paired with 2018 Cy Young winner award winner Blake Snell, the duo provides a nice 1-2 punch before they start playing "opener" ball (look it up).
The Rays are young and talented, and if they're in the mix by mid July, and I think they will be, I suspect they might spend a few extra dollars to add some help; and since I didn't put any "respec" on their name last year, go ahead and put me down as predicting they'll be a wild card team.
Texas Rangers/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
Last year the Rangers had all kinds of problems. Sure they can put up runs, thanks in large part to their stadium, but their pitching was bad. The Rangers had the second worse starter era in the majors. To make matters worse, they committed the third most errors in the bigs.
Not a good formula for winning.
Adding Lance Lynn was a good start to bolstering the rotation, and adding Zach McAllister and Shawn Kelley helps make a soso bullpen better, but those three along with the other pedestrian moves they made this off season is probably not enough to make them relevant.
They'll battle Seattle for last place in the division.
Toronto Blue Jay/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
For a team that's getting younger and better, I really liked their off season moves. Every player they added made them better, and they have who many feel is the number one prospect in baseball in Vladimir Guerrero Jr. ready to break out (and don't forget they also have 2 other "sons of former players" who could make an impact in Bo Bichette and Cavan Biggio...yes THAT Biggio).
Toronto will be sellers at the deadline, as they still need to get rid of some "old guys", but I think this team might surprise a few folks. If I had to describe them in one word, I'd say "scrappy".
MLB/Facebook
There is a lot of parity in the NL this year, and that should make for 3 exciting races in each of the divisions. The NL Central, while it doesn't have one of the six best teams in baseball, has five really good teams. It should end up being the best division in baseball. In fact, the NL is so good this year it's possible that only the Marlins and Giants will be among the 10 worst teams in baseball, the other eight could all come from the AL.
Arizona Diamondbacks/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
The DBacks felt so close. It was just two years ago that they won 93 games, earned a wild card birth where they beat division rival Colorado for the right to get swept by other division rival the Dodgers.
That 2017 team looked like it had it all, a top 10 offense, and a top five rotation and bullpen.
But then 2018 happened, and everything went in the wrong direction. They went from eighth in the league in runs scored in 2017, to 19th in 2018. They can still pitch but the fifth best rotation is baseball fell to the bottom of the top 10, and the bullpen regressed as well. It all added up to two games above .500 and missing the playoffs.
So instead of bringing in more veteran players that can help, they ship of one of the best players in baseball in Paul Goldschmidt to the St. Louis for what many believe were three players (Weaver, Kelly, Young) that while good, were far below what Goldy should have brought back.
I can't really figure out the 2019 Diamondbacks. They can still pitch, and they'll probably be in the top of the league in runs scored, but I just don't think they have enough to hang with the Rockies or the Dodgers, and they better be looking over their shoulder because here comes the Padres.
Atlanta Braves/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
Well I didn't see that coming. I wrote last year that Atlanta was a team on the come, and that I thought they were still "a few years away from the playoffs, but not as far as you might think." Well, I guess they were even closer than I thought.
The upstart Braves shocked the baseball world, won 90 games and ran away with a bad division. Acuna was what we thought he was (a freaking STUD), Freeman was MVP caliber, and the list of good young players goes on and on.
I don't like the Josh Donaldson signing but if he's healthy he could bolster their lineup.
I like what's going on in Atlanta, and I think they'll be a fun and exciting team to watch, but I don't know if they have enough pitching to compete with the Nationals or the Mets, or for that matter the firepower to hang with the Phillies.
Chicago Cubs/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
The Cubs have been good for a while now, but a ho hum offseason means they really didn't do much to get better. Brach helps improve the bullpen, but other than "veteran presence" I'm not sure what else Descalso brings to the table.
Theo Epstein has hinted that 2019 could be a win or else season. I don't think that to be true, but he has to say something to motivate them right?
The lovable losers will be in a dog fight with the Brewers all season long, but because I think the NL East is loaded, and the Brewers are just a bit better, I think the Cubs miss the playoffs this year.
BUT…
Between us gals, it won't surprise me if any of the big three in the division (Cards, Cubs, or Brewers) make the playoffs.
Cincinnati Reds/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
GM Nick Krall got to work this off season, and it showed. Most of the additions to the roster came via Trade, but it's clear the Reds are ready to make a push, and If you're Joey Votto you have to be thinking "IT'S ABOUT TIME!"
They have retooled the rotations by adding Gray and Roark, and put some weapons around Vatto in Kemp and Puig.
They'll be better than last year, but on paper they look to be 1 or 2 more moves away from contending for the division.
Colorado Rockies/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
The Rockies are solid, and have been for a few years now (if you need proof, they went to the playoffs for two years in a row now, something they've never accomplished in team history before). Bud Black has done a fantastic job as a manager, and it really shows with the pitching staff. This group of arms, and the success they have at Coors field, is thanks in large part to Black and his coaching staff.
In the off season they added a solid stick in Daniel Murphy to compliment the outstanding trio of Arenado, Blackmon, and Story, but LeMahieu leaving hurts, and the loss of Ottavino is going to hurt an already suspect bullpen.
They need a full, healthy season from Dahl, and they need better outings from Shaw and Bettis out of the pen.
As is the case in just about every season for the Rockies, if they can get good pitching to compliment their hitting, they'll give teams fits.
Now look, my formulas and whatnot tell me the Rockies won't win the division, but I'm not a believer in the Dodgers this year. That said, I have to trust my numbers so I think whoever doesn't win the NL West will barely miss out on the wild card to the Mets, and my data says that's the Rockies...but put me down for saying I think the Rockies could win the West outright and the Dodgers could miss the playoffs.
Los Angeles Dodgers/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
The more I study this team, the more I think the Dodgers took a step back this offseason. They lost a lot of talent. A.J. Pollock is a solid replacement in the outfield that lost both Matt Kemp and Yasiel Puig, but it's not enough to replace their combined 44 HR and 148 RBIs.
From the "well duh" department, Kershaw's health is going to be of utmost importance to this squad.
The Rockies got better, and I think the Dodgers got worse. Not like bad, but I don't think they are as good as they were last year. I know the sexy pick is to have them back in the World Series, and my numbers and formulas tell me to make them the division winner so I will, but I'll go on record and say the Rockies could very well win this division and the Dodger could miss the playoffs all together.
There, I said it.
Miami Marlins/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
Rebuilding...and not doing a good job of it.
Milwaukee Brewers/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
I have mixed feelings about the Brewers offseason.
I like the Grandal and Moustakas signings, their rotation got worse, and somehow their bullpen got better.
Their core four of: 2018 NL MVP Christian Yelich, Lorenzo Cain (6.9 WAR, 2nd in the NL only to Yellich who had a 7.6), power hitting second baseman Travis, Shaw, and the fast rising slugger Jesus Aguilar means the Brew Crew should still but up gaudy numbers at the plate, but the Loss of Wade Miley took a bad rotation and made it worse.
Their Bullpen might be the best in all of baseball, especially if they add former Red Sox closer Craig Kimbrel (rumor is he'll either be a Brewer or a Brave).
All that said they have a solid squad, and I think the central is theirs to lose.
New York Mets/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
The Mets got what they needed this offseason: hitting and bullpen help.
I love the trade they pulled off with the Mariners that addressed both of those by adding Cano and Diaz. In fact, I actually like prety much all of the signings they made. They're deeper than they were last year, and thus better.
The NL East is LOADED, and you could make a case for any team in the division not named the Marlins winning the division. I don't think the Mets will win the division, but I do think they'll grab the 2nd wild card spot.
Philadelphia Phillies/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
Stop me if you heard this before, but the Phillies got better in the offseason.
It's hard to argue that they won't be better after adding stud hitters like Bryce Harper and J.T. Realmuto, but this young Phillies squad got deeper too.
There's no doubt they'll score runs, and a middle of the road bullpen got a lot deeper when they added David Robertson, Alvarez and Nicasio.
They hit the ground running last year, but faded late. I think they'll be a lot of fun to watch, and will be a wild card team at the very least, and could be as good as winning the division.
Pittsburgh Pirates/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
The Pirates are a few years away, but I really like the direction they are headed. They have a really good pitching staff, but failed to add a big bat this offseason.
My number crunching says that on paper, the Pirates are the third best team in the division, but my gut tells me they're headed for a fourth place finish.
San Diego Padres/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
Don't look now, but Fernando Tatis Jr has made the 25 man opening roster. Him and Machado will be a dynamic duo on the left side of the Padres' infield for many years to come.
I think the Padres got markedly better in the offseason, and that's following a 2018 campaign when they did better than I thought they would.
I'm not saying they are ready yet, but when you invest what they did in Machado, you assume winning is the No. 1 priority. I don't know if the team has enough to overtake the Dodgers or Rockies, but they'll be in the hunt all year.
San Francisco Giants/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
The giants were very busy last offseason, and all that activity resulted in a win increase of just nine games, but...After 24 years as a manager in the Majors,Bruce Bochy announced that 2019 will be his last year, and while they Giants got younger compared to their team age at this time last year, I'm not sure they got much better. Plus they're in a tough division, so expect about the same as last year in Bochy's farewell tour.
St. Louis Cardinals/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
I'm really not sure about this Cardinals team. They pretty much stole Paul Goldschmidt from the Diamondbacks, and Andrew Miller makes a bullpen that had the 11th worst era in the majors better.
They could use a bounceback year from Marcell Ozuna, whose numbers dipped after coming over from the Marlins, and if they get it that along with GoldSchmidt, Carpenter this lineup could give other teams nightmares.
Their rotation is middle of the road at best, and while improved the bullpen could still use some help.
This is one of the teams this year that my numbers/formulas say one thing but eyes tell me another, except unlike most of the others I think the Cardinals might be better than my numbers tell me. They play in one of the toughest and most balanced divisions in baseball, and I don't think they are better than the Brewers or Cubs, but despite my spreadsheet telling me they'll end fourth in the division, it won't surprise me if they finish as high as second.
Washington Nationals/Facebook
Key Additions:
Key Losses:
Nats left fielder Juan Soto (.292/.406/.517) is a stud and it could be a matter of just months until he has Nats fans saying, "Bryce who?"
Along with Soto, they have my pick for rookie of the year
In fact, here's a fun fact about last years Nationals team: Bryce Harper had the fourth highest WAR (1.3) on the team, behind Anthony Rendon (4.2) Trey Turner (4.1) and Soto (3.0).
Don't get me wrong, replacing Harper's 34 home runs and 100 RBI isn't easy, but they Nats have the bats.
OK, that was unintentional.
More than the bats though, the Washington Nationals have a NASTY rotation. The addition of Patrick Corbin and Anibal Sanchez makes the Nationals rotation one of the best in baseball.
They have one of the best rotations in baseball, and finally seem to have resolved the bullpen issues that have plagued them the past couple of seasons.
Despite losing Harper the team is built to win now and after a disappointing 2018 I foresee a bounceback year and have them rated as the best team in the National League.MLB/Facebook
And now we come to my predictions!
I'll be real honest with you...at this point, I'm pretty sick of looking at this computer screen, so let's just cut the BS and get to it! Below is my predictions based on several factors. I created a formula that I used based on various stats to come up with a rating for each team.
THE LOWER NUMBER, THE BETTER THAN TEAM IS.
My division winners are:
AL: Yankees, Indians, Astros
NL: Nationals, Brewers, Dodgers
My Wild Card winners are:
AL: Red Sox, Rays
NL: Phillies, Mets
WORLD SERIES: YANKEES def. NATIONALS
Yankees - 2.00
Red Sox (WC 1) - 8.33
Rays (WC 2) - 13.67
Blue Jays - 19.33
Orioles - 28.00
Indians - 7.33
Twins - 13.33
White Sox - 22.67
Tigers - 27.00
Royals - 28.00
Astros - 4.33
Athletics - 15.67
Angels - 17.00
Rangers - 18.33
Mariners - 24.83
Nationals - 7.00
Phillies (WC 1) - 11.33
Mets (WC 2) - 11.67
Braves - 16.00
Marlins - 26.67
Brewers - 11.83
Cubs - 13.00
Pirates - 13.33
Cardinals - 15.67
Reds - 17.67
Dodgers - 7.50
Rockies - 11.67
Padres - 15.33
D'backs - 15.83
Giants - 20.67
MLB/Facebook
Here are my award Predictions for 2019.
AL:
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (Blue Jays)
NL:
Victor Robles (Nationals)
AL:
Trevor Bauer (Cleveland)
NL:
Max Scherzer (Nationals)
AL:
Aaron Judge (Yankees)
NL:
Bryce Harper (Phillies)
Thanks for reading. Enjoy the season.
The woeful state of the Astros' farm system has made it very expensive to continue maintaining a good team, prohibitively so (in part self-imposed) from having a great team. Even if they re-sign Alex Bregman, trading Framber Valdez and/or Kyle Tucker for prospects could snap the Astros' run of eight straight postseason appearances. But if they KNOW that no way do they intend to offer Framber five years 130 million dollars, Tucker 7/225 or whatever their free agent markets might be after next season, keeping them for 2025 but getting nothing but 2026 compensatory draft picks for them could do multi-year damage to the franchise.
Preliminary Kyle Tucker trade talks between the Astros and Cubs involve both Seiya Suzuki and Isaac Paredes, sources tell @Ken_Rosenthal and me - https://t.co/kIRATDQpEn
— Chandler Rome (@Chandler_Rome) December 11, 2024
The time is here for the Astros to be aggressively shopping both. It doesn't make trading them obligatory, but even though many purported top prospects amount to little or nothing (look up what the Astros traded to Detroit for Justin Verlander, to Pittsburgh for Gerrit Cole, to Arizona for Zack Greinke) if strong packages are offered the Astros need to act if unwilling (reasonably or not) to pay Valdez/Tucker.
Last offseason the Milwaukee Brewers traded pitching ace Corbin Burnes one season ahead of his free agency and then again won the National League Central, the San Diego Padres dealt Juan Soto and wound up much improved and a playoff team after missing the 2023 postseason. But nailing the trades is critical. The Brewers got their everyday rookie third baseman Joey Ortiz and two other prospects. The Padres got quality starter Michael King, catcher Kyle Hagashioka, and three prospects.
Back to Bregman
Meanwhile, decision time approaches for Alex Bregman. He, via agent Scott Boras, wants 200-plus million dollars. Don't we all. If he can land that from somebody, congratulations. The Astros' six-year 156 million dollar contract offer is more than fair. That's 26 million dollars per season and would take Bregman within a few months of his 37th birthday. If rounding up to 160 mil gets it done, ok I guess. Going to 200 would be silly.
While Bregman hasn't been a superstar (or even an All-Star) since 2019, he's still a very good player. That includes his 2024 season which showed decline offensively. Not falling off a cliff decline other than his walk rate plunging about 45 percent, but decline. If Bregman remains the exact player he was this season, six-156 is pricey but not crazy in the current marketplace. But how likely is Bregman to not drop off further in his mid-30s? As noted before, the storyline is bogus that Bregman has been a postseason monster. Over seven League Championship Series and four World Series Bregman has a .196 batting average.
The Astros already should be sweating some over Jose Altuve having shown marked decline this season, before his five year 125 million dollar extension covering 2025-2029 even starts. Altuve was still very good offensively though well down from 2022 and 2023 (defensively his data are now awful), but as he approaches turning 35 years old in May some concern is warranted when locked into paying a guy until he's nearly 39 1/2.
Jim Crane is right in noting that long contracts paying guys huge money in their later years generally go poorly for the clubs.
Bang for your buck
Cleveland third baseman Jose Ramirez is heading into the second year of a five-year, $124 million extension. That's 24.8 million dollars per season. Jose Ramirez is a clearly better player than Alex Bregman. Ramirez has been the better player for five consecutive seasons, and only in 2023 was it even close. It should be noted that Ramirez signed his extension in April of 2022. He is about a year and a half older than Bregman so the Guardians are paying their superstar through his age 36 season.
Bregman benefits from playing his home games at soon-to be named Daikin Park. Bregman hit 26 home runs this year. Using ball-tracking data, if he had played all his games in Houston, Bregman would have hit 31 homers. Had all his swings been taken at Yankee Stadium, the "Breggy Bomb" count would have been 25. In Cleveland, just 18. Ramirez hit 41 dingers. If all his games were home games 40 would have cleared the fences, if all had been at Minute Maid Park 47 would have been gone.
Matt Chapman recently signed a six-year 151 million dollar deal to stay with the San Francisco Giants. That's 25.166 million per season. Chapman was clearly a better player than Bregman this year. But it's the only season of Chapman's career that is the case. Chapman is 11 months older than Bregman, so his lush deal with the Giants carries through his age 37 season.
The Giants having overpaid Chapman doesn't obligate the Astros to do the same with Bregman. So, if you're the Astros do you accept overpaying Bregman? They would almost certainly be worse without him in 2025, but what about beyond? Again, having not one elite prospect in their minor league system boxes them in. Still, until/unless the Seattle Mariners upgrade their offense, the Astros cling to American League West favorites status. On the other hand, WITH Bregman, Tucker, and Valdez the Astros are no postseason lock.
For Texans’ conversation, catch Brandon Strange, Josh Jordan, and me on our Texans On Tap podcasts. Thursdays feature a preview of the upcoming game, and then we go live (then available on demand) after the final gun of the game: Texans on Tap - YouTube
The Astros are always in season for discussion. Our Stone Cold ‘Stros podcasts drop Mondays: Click here to watch!